View Single Post
Originally Posted by tabby View Post
Okay, great take. You are completely right and I agree. Sorry gang. If this is the only aspect of my reply you care about you may ignore the rest

I thought about making it a separate thread, but I did not consider how it would read when placed in this one. Rajen came to me asking to write a tier list with him, but I elected to just write one on my own because I thought it would be fun, and potentially a cool read, and I like talking about ukebash replays. I see now that in me gushing about the pros and cons of all my favourite ukebashers I blatantly just look like an elitist prick. It is disheartening, you are right. This type of content is better suited elsewhere and, frankly, I want to revise it some to do some of the lower placements way more justice

I did not mean any harm by it, but I can see how this type of reply to what is in essence a wholesome thread is pretty harmful. I appreciate you voicing this. I wanted to offer some substance in my reply, but clearly I've missed the mark completely

likewise, great response. not what i expected, makes me respect u a lot more after the impression that tier list post initially gave me

i think u understood my point perfectly (despite the delivery) and i appreciate that a lot

I think instead of a trying-to-be-objective-but-definitely-subjective tier list perhaps I will instead just edit the post to extensively talk about all of the players I have liked throughout my own ukebash journey and how they have shaped my understanding of the game in subtle ways. I don't feel like writing that this very second though, because I spent a long time writing that other nonsense, so instead I am going to just can the tier list to a notepad file and replace the post with a gif until I come up with something

this is perfectly valid and constructive to do, and the right approach to something like this imo, so long as no one is being needlessly disparaged

apologies for the strong language i used, i found the tone and purpose of the post to be disagreeable, even if it wasn't ur intent. but i'm glad we're on the same page and i don't think ur a mean-spirited person anymore!!!