I give them a yes but it's majority rules so I'll wait to see if we have more voters.

I don't consider this an alt due to his main being banned and I respect the fact that he admitted to it rather than us finding out that he was hiding it.

I can vouch that he's quite good in game.

So far votes are
1 neutral
2 yes
1 no

If we get another no with valid reasoning then it's probably a rejection,
if we get another yes with valid reasoning then it's probably a pass.