I hear what you're saying Gabe, and while I do admit the whole door thing sounds good, I don't think it would fit the theme of either banners at this point. As for the bits around everything else I'm personally fine with them, there is nothing else I can think of being better, so I'm not going to complain about whats good.

Though the text in the other banners needs to be fixed, its lither than the logo test so I would like to see all the other banners darkened to be like the logo. As for the line through the text in the other banners I'm not 100% sure, but I feel like they are just there because the text is too dark, though you might have done something else. Darken the text on the others and lets see where that takes us.

Edit: I agree with Pouffywall on the asymmetrical thing and adding differences in each flame, but as for that line in the middle I still say just darken the text first and lets see if that makes it more like the Logo, The logo is perfect, get the text of everything else like the logo text.
Also as for the differences in the flames, even if they are small it will be fine, they don't have to be vastly different.