I mean you can't criticize a movie without the things like the acting and the actors and what goes in in the movie.

So i believe the replays play an important roll in the emotion, mood and feel of the video as a whole. It's part of the visuals.

as far as what im looking for criticism on, is not the replays and their skill level or strictly the things like transitions and cc and etc. but rather how the movements of the tori and the camera throughout the space create/set a mood and tone and whether that tone or mood was successfully achieved.

for example.

A scene where a guy is getting punched.

I don't want CNC on how good the punch was like technique

and i don't want CNC on the color, cc, and effects that happen on screen with the punch.

I want CNC on how the punch was portrayed and shown and if it contributes to the feel/mood and tone the scene is going for. Like a totally serious scene can be ruined by a silly looking punch.

but its not silly because of the technique or the colors and CC, but rather how it was shown, the timing, the build up of mood.