So, lots of people really want wibbles. Some people don't want wibbles. I say just try it. Make it so you're required to be logged in, put some moderators on it, and see how it goes for a week or two. If it turns out to be an absolutely horrible idea, remove it.

Personally, I really see no reason whatsoever for wibbles to not make a comeback. Pretty much every reason against it seemed trivial compared to the heightened sense of community and fun that could come with a wibbles board. Different adjustments and rules could easily be made to prevent whatever problems that may arise from it. #bumpingforWIBBLES

(by the way, no one I know that has purchased toriprime did it for the tp board. I'm going to purchase it soon, and it never even really registered to me that there was a special tp board before reading this thread.)