I understand it's not supposed to be a real move because you want to pin your name to it which I have no problem with. But if you keep flip flopping what the technique is then it's really no technique at all. I did the roux whip exactly as you showed me and holy shit it works, pretty well I might add.

But having requirements to "whip him violently" makes no damn sense because there's always variables we can't control.
And I would add that the move works just as good against a tall based opponent as it does against a floating based opponent.