All sounds like a good idea to me apart from the issue with CnC. As well as what Pynt said, my other worry is that the replays forum becomes like the art forum, where it seems like shitty comments are allowed because they imply something which can be changed thus being constructive, whereas people who like the art and just want to say that they like it have their posts deleted because that's not constructive enough. (I haven't been there that recently though so maybe it's got better who knows)

But then again, if some sort of comment isn't enforced, nobody will comment or really even look at eachother's because let's face it most people will just want to show-off their replay and not care enough to go through everyone else's. And then if we just required a comment of any kind then a lot of people will most likely post 1 word responses or such.

Would be great if there was a regular 'replay of the week' where the best replay posted on the thread that week would get added to the first post, which would then be a collection of the best replays. Although that would require someone to volunteer for that job and it sounds like a lot of work and would need someone who knows a thing or 2 about replays. If AssassinPro didn't already have too many jobs then I'd suggest him.

sassy Moderated Message:

any replay lmod can do that

Seems like a hard thing to make work even though it seems like a great idea. Not sure I have any answers. I hope you make it work though