Trying to give some different answers from who I and other people usually mention, I think Airoblinn was very cool even though I dont have that many replays by him. Splinter was also really great.

Of recent years i think NICOLAS135 is the best
http://forum.toribash.com/attachment...7&d=1460660213
http://forum.toribash.com/attachment...6&d=1462285822
and Private has some great replays too.