I read this pretty closely and tbh it seems like it'll work. The whole thing about not factoring out inactives was really fucking scary but seeing the list of clans that failed and that 50% thing you were talking about, it's fine with me

however
has there been any thought put into the deofficial meaning you have to get active using just one thread?
there was an event that made clans unofficial if they didn't place first
obey enter and didnt win, which was fine
the fact that we only had one thread all of a sudden killed us though, the only reason we got active again is because we invited some ally's to the clan to basically post nonsense convos until we got official again
once that happened, we all got back into it

having just one thread made things really bad though, don't you think it's just making things even harder for clans struggling and actually trying to get back?
-----
also there's still the issue of when you kill a clan with some godlike kinda inactive player in it (that still hangs around), they tend to just quit the game for good (where is Nuthug and Oblivion now?)

are you sure this is a benefit to the game and community