Originally Posted by
sir
You suggested two completely different things in your posts, I responded to one that didn't make any sense at all in hopes that it won't be ever brought up again. First time you complained about us not allowing clans to specify who to exclude from checks, second time you complained about small clans getting an advantage due to having less players.
Then why did you respond to my 'second' suggestion with an explanation that has nothing to do with it? You responded as if I were making my first suggestion (which wasn't really a suggestion anyway, just an observation).
You didn't read my post. That's why only now, below, are you responding to the actual point I made in it.
Originally Posted by
sir
Second complaint is legit, I can agree that there should be a minimum required amount of players for official clans to get full points for activity. Historically, clans system treats any clan with over 5 members as active, and with 50% members active required to get full points it means that such a clan can have only three members playing the game to pass the ingame activity check.
My 'complaint' isn't about installing a minimum required amount of players for full activity. It's about ensuring that the level of activity required for a passing grade is the same among all clans.
Originally Posted by
sir
Regarding that Team A Team B thing... Honestly, you're arguing for the sake of it here (as usual?). Team A has 100% of its members active and thus is active as a whole, whereas Team B isn't. That's it and you can't argue with that.
Actually I know that you can and most probably will, but that'd make no sense.
What does it matter that Team A is 'active as a whole'? Team B has just as many active people. Why should Team B fail?
The task these teams have isn't to develop some major project before a deadline. The task is playing a turn-based physics game. Why punish Team B for not being 'active as a whole', when they have just the same (or more) people playing than Team A? What
sense does that make?
Last edited by Ele; Oct 15, 2018 at 02:59 PM.