Probably because our criteria of clean is different. A clean replay for me is one that ends up with Uke having 0 points. You took 165 points during the hit. Even though that's a small amount, I like splits when they are absolutely flawless, because it's something so simple and bland.
It's totally understandable if you think different, but I usually ignore CnC due to the fact that it's a matter of opinion whether a replay is good or not.

Ono 165 point iss so bad.
I don't look at the points on replays, I look at the replays.
I look at the movement etc.

Point's don't matter to me.

Edit: I can see that my post can come across as slightly butthurt.
I guess like you said, it's your opinion. I'll respect it.

I already said we all have a different opinion in replays, I think that's true.


EDIT
Just saw your edit, and I felt like my old post was a bit too assholish regarding your new post, so there you go.

ok.

Edit: lol just saw yours.

Alright I'm done arguing.

change my slogan to whatever you feel like

Make up something, duuu

Hours, I did fix it up. c:
Thanks for quoting it again so it wouldn't get buried.

/relevant.
So yeah, I'm off soon, just posting this wherever I need to.

Butler isnt really updating first post.

I have asked about three times here to change my slogan and my custom pick...

I am just too lazy to edit stuff right now.. Lol.. Will do it tomorrow or something..
Also 2000th post \o/