Based on how active and loyal you have been id say yes, But based on your in game skills Id say no. I don't think you bring anything new at an In Game level. You are probably the highest skilled black belt I know and you knowledge of the forums is 'very' good.
I don't know where my vote lies, I'm on the fence.

I also continue my theory with no other evidence than gut instinct that he is a criminal alt
Maybe ill save my thinkings for another time.

Same happen to me, You showed alot activity and effort, but we all know that you are a "new" guy and your in-game skills are not impressive. Anyway we know that you can learn alot and become a great player, I'm tempted to give you a yes, but I will wait a bit more...

Based Neko.

Also for Xguard, he's a really cool chop to hang with. Fisto and Shade already said everything, especially when we were talking about heighten our standards for the ingame part. Leaning towards Yes and No, i have no idea since the replays also didn't show anything special.

No from me to XGuard

i dont see anything special here, its actually below average. maybe if you up ur replay game you might get a yes from me.
but for now no

also i made a replay but i dont think its good enough to go in the replay board

-20 is the new -30

I thought we were married
-----
THINK OF OUR CHILDREN

For XGuard i'll say no aswell (sorry bud). I don't know if the excuse "he improves fast" counts here, since he is going to represent us in clan wars and events. There is nothing against him hanging around with us and learning things and all. If he really improves fast he could apply again later. I'd still count us to an ingame clan and we should really look for who to invite, even if XGuard is a really nice dude.

Not getting accepted just means that he isn't wearing the (Trib- ... erm, excuse me, [Tribe] tag in front of his name. He techically already belongs to us, but there wouldn't be a real use for him in wars or events. That's just my point of view. Improve your game and i'm sure we will invite you anyways some day when we saw your improvements.

no to xguard also, sorry bro, belt up and gain some experience, but pls dont stop hanging out with us, you are cool

halo xguard, I like you and you should come hang in #hi with me and ishi and other people from the internet I like as well.
also yes from me
-----

What kind of farmer plants no seeds but expects to harvest a ripe fruit?
Seeing as the only concern about xguard seems to be the green behind his ears we could easily grasp for other methods other than rejection to force him to grow into the fag you folks expect.
I SAY put him on trial for one whole year. Surely that is enough to grow some plants out of his ears. He cannot participate in clanwars, join clanevents, vote on other people etc during that time. Once the trial ends he gets tested again and either thrown out or integrated.
Everyone in favor say aye.