It's sad to see nobody utilized the lattice properly ;~;
But nah, the point system is fine. I can explain the match you were talking about step by step on how people got points.
1.) Through random scuffles (mostly a kick to your thigh) asdguy accumulates around 5k points.
2.) You decently punch asdguy in the head, getting around 15k points.
3.) You unsuccessfully kick asdguy, and then pull his shin with you leg (by contracting knee) and slam it right into your ass (whoops!) giving him around 7k more points, with a total of 12k points.
4.) Asdguy punches(ish) your ass, giving him 3k more points over a couple turns, giving a total of around 15k points.
5.) You kick asdguy's lumbar, giving you another 5k points, giving a total of around 20k points.
6.) Match ends with scores of 20736 to 15195, Wizard wins.
So, essentially, how this match was played was you had one single decent hit and a single minor hit, and asdguy had more than a few minor hits, which is why you ended up with relatively close scores.
The point system isn't messy. In fact, it's a vast improvement from the point system used in mods like lenshu and rk-mma. (the matches between Victor and Assassinpro are a good representation of that) However... I do think I see a problem (although mostly unrelated to your match). I'll alert StrikingReborn (who I took the point distribution from) and reupload a fixed version. PM me if you want to whine about why you almost lost some more.