Feedback. Spending more time on the negatives since it's more important to know what sucked than what was good.
At least imho.
The problems:
#1 Interest
When starting to build a song up figure out your point of interest. In this case your driving force is the intro synth that keeps repeating throughout the song. The problem with it is that it doesn't do anything.
There is no real progression and the short melody it follows is to say crudely quite obnoxious.
#2 Fill it up.
Think about how to fill up the production reasonably. Currently you have pretty clean and thin melody synth, sub, kick, a small pluck and some percs.
If you have only a few intruments make sure they are individually fat so that the track doesn't feel empty. In this case you run into problems since the synth nor the bass occupy more than a small slice of the total frequency range.
#3 Compositional structure
Currently the song just loops the same thing while adding one or two percs once in a while in there.
Even in a laid back "chill" track, there needs to be progression to keep the listeners interest up. This can be a new element added that changes the dynamic of the song or an entirely different chord progression and instrumentation. It doesn't always need to be radical.
But there needs to be something.
#4 Sound design
The synths did not sound good. The lead synth being the big problem, it certainly wouldn't want to listen to that looping for a long time. The same applies for the sub bass, its functional but boring. When there are no other bass elements than a singular sub bass, it needs to be thicker and more interesting. Same applies for the percs. Most of the percs are just there, they don't have much dynamics nor pop to them.
Positives:
Balance
Everything is mostly in a good balance nothing is massively too loud nor quiet, sure the perc mixing is a bit lackluster but the general balance is there.
Cleanness
The track is easy to follow and not too crowded. (a bit empty) Many beginners make tracks that are way too crowded and hard to follow, which wasn't the case here.
Theme
All the instruments were thematically similar and there were no outliers in the sounds. Everything kept to a similar theme.
Last edited by cowmeat; Jan 4, 2017 at 11:28 AM.