This is by far the best explanation of this, since I'm rather bad at getting my point across.
You like Harem anime? Watch that shit.
You like Magical Girls? Watch that shit.
You like cliche anime? Watch that shit.
You like Manga? Read that shit.
I can't get into Manga and tend to enjoy anime where the main character is an overpowered underdog. That's my fetish dude. Including anime that just make me cry uncontrollably.
Watch what you enjoy and don't worry about what other people think. Their opinion isn't fact.