So here it is.
Song: Falloutboy - Thnks Fr the mmrs or something along the lines of that

Recording Software: Fraps

Editing Software: Movie Maker :I

Replay Makers:
Irrita
Starstorm
Apex119
Osiris

Replay 5, 'game' box was showing
-1
All in all, could've had more sync, Recording was also a bit laggy
6.5/10

I can't really help the laggy recording, I'll try to sync it better and I'll be sure to remove that game box.

Alright, thank you.

*puts hands up* woah there, no sugar coating here. I use movie maker so I have a limited amount of tools to work with. As for the replays, we aren't that great, give us some time. :P

I'm not really ready to buy a $200+ editing program like sony vegas or anything like that. :P

If you would have read my first post entirely, you would have seen that I use movie maker. :I

Song had a good amount of potential. There wasn't much syncing, though.

The recording got a bit laggy at points, and I couldn't tell what was happening half the time. It was pretty jerky at points. Transitions to different replays were really rough as well.

5.5/10 overall

The sentence "I use movie maker" basically explains all of the reasons you don't like it. I'll most likely be getting Sony Vegas by Christmas.

i don't know very much about vid making, but i know which is good or need improvement.
It would be better if put some effect on it, like transition,light, or something like that.
You could put more effort on synching. The replay overall is good, and you already choose a good song for it.

Keep it up, mates.

The video serves well as a replay showcase which is essentially what clan videos are for. So good work on keeping the viewers attention on the replays and not an overabundance of random effects and jump cuts. However making a video in windows movie maker is probably your biggest issue here which I'm sure you've already established. Pretty good video in all honesty for what you had to make do with. Good job and keep working towards improving and maybe getting some better editing software.