Hi, I ran this in tourney13 over the past few days:


Overall the response to this modlist was positive, although there was less discussion / reaction to this change than I expected. Currently the modlist has been reverted to how it was before these changes, but I'm looking to you guys to tell me if this new list is preferable, if there should be changes and so on.

Main points of discussion:

• Should T13 run this list?
• What mods on the list should be changed if any?
• Should other rooms also be looked at?

What would you replace ringen with then? I included it so there was a non-standard mod mixed in with the familiar faces - perhaps it could be swapped out for a weapon mod or some other non-standard mod. Or it could be removed entirely?

fearlegs.tbm

Erthtk is already in the rotation, not to mention tk is extremely unpopular outside of its dedicated circles. There's a general feeling that the mod isn't fun at all when tryharding.

Judofrac could be cool, however?

i'd like to see judofrac and maybe some variation of a wushu mod (like wushu3dome-tbm wushu2015.tbm)

but i dont think wushu is very popular :[

other then that i got nothing to add

A bit bummed out by reaction to ringen4, though it's not that surprising. It's vastly different from your run of the mill mods. Sometimes I feel like people just want a supply of familiar aikido/TK/lenshu clones, forever.

But, no, you don't "just hug til you fall over" in ringen unless you don't know what you're doing. Attached are some examples of how you're supposed to play the mod, in case someone cares.

If people don't like it then you should probably take it out. Maybe add murden_5 that I just uploaded (sturdier limbs, less points for wrist hits, 3 extra frames dq timeout). Or maybe pillar_of_ghosts.

Instead of erthTk because its total trash put Judofrac in instead.

Guys, this is an Off-topic thread. If you have proposals or you support something, please explain why - I'm letting prior posts slide but stuff like 'supported' is just going to be deleted.

I'm extremely against adding wushu or normal taekkyon. Neither of these mods are fun at all to play with tryharding strangers - with friends going for cool boomhits or smooth motion perhaps but not with randoms. Tk has a huge flaw in that snapkick openers are overbearingly powerful and wrists are far too weak. Wushu is cruddy in general - wushudome is perhaps slightly preferable however?

Right now I'm very tempted to run:

erthtkv2.tbm, aikidobigdojo.tbm, lenshu3ng(or lenshuf!), greykido.tbm, rk-mma.tbm judofrac.tbm, boxshu_mushu_v3.tbm

Will run in 24h from this post unless people have serious objections

Worth noting that almost all hate posts about ringen are from the same person on different accounts.
Personally I like ringen and a lot of other people do too, but you can't make everyone happy when it come to things like these.