Originally Posted by
ynvaser
Actually, removing or undermining those brutal dictators (like Hussein or Assad) caused all the bloodshed we see today. That same bloodshed everybody is running from... towards Europe.
Killing Gaddafi in Libya removed a big chunk of the Northern African barrier that kept the masses from running. Stabilizing the region would take another ground war, and then installing new dictators to keep the ISIS stuff from repeating itself.
So yeah, thanks USA. Let's hope whoever comes to it's helm next will try to fix this mess.
So, your strategy for peace in the Middle East is to do what we've been doing since the breakup of the Ottoman Empire and just clamp down on dissent?
Dissent is a symptom of people being unhappy with their government. When developing long-term solutions, we need to think about dealing with the disease itself (people unhappy with their govt), rather than the symptoms of the disease.
So why are people so unhappy with their govt? Mainly because their govt doesn't represent them. In several key Middle Eastern states (such as Iraq) a minority religious group is in charge over a majority group. It's this way because after WW1, the West carved up the former Ottoman Empire, deciding which great power got control of which areas. They didn't create the borders of the Middle East by looking at which ethnic group lived in which area and by giving each their own nation, but decided it by lumping together all sorts of people because the combined land they lived in was seen as more bountiful. The borders of the Middle East that we created after WW1 don't reflect how the border would be were the people of the Middle East given a say in the matter.
After we carved up the borders, we eventually decided that colonialism was a bit old-world, so we decolonialised the Middle East. We left them with dictators that would support the interests of the West and oppress their people with iron fists so that the beneficial partnership the West set up with them would continue. You're proposing that we regress 70 years and do this again.
The borders of the Middle East need to readjust back to their natural frontiers. This can happen through war between the Middle Eastern nations/NSAs or perhaps through some big endogenic political summit. Whichever way it happens,
the West should not be involved in it. Us perpetuating the unnatural borders we established for our own gain will never bring the Middle East peace. The very best thing we can do is cease all military involvement.
Last edited by Ele; Sep 1, 2015 at 03:38 PM.